Guide · Core, Surgery and trauma, Medicines and results

From patient intake form to consultation: starting with the history already taken

Written for
Hospital physicians, clinic doctors and residents
Reading time
5 minutes
Published
Updated

Written by the Sana Health team for clinicians. It summarises published guidance, is not a guideline and has not been peer reviewed. Check current local protocols before acting.

Key points

  • The clinician shares a link, the patient fills in an intake form, and the clinician can start a consultation in any of the 38 engines from the patient's answers.
  • A patient-completed history gathers background before the consultation, leaving more of the clinician's time for the problem itself.
  • It is a starting point, not a finished history: the presenting complaint, red flags, medicines and allergies must be confirmed with the patient.
  • Patients describe symptoms in their own words, so check what they meant before translating answers into clinical terms.
  • Add examination findings, observations and results before asking an engine for an opinion.
  • An intake form is not a triage tool, and the clinician remains responsible for every decision.

How the workflow runs

  1. The clinician shares a link to an intake form with the patient, for example ahead of a clinic appointment.
  2. The patient fills in the form, describing the problem and their background in their own words.
  3. The clinician reads the answers and confirms the key points with the patient.
  4. From those answers the clinician starts a consultation in whichever engine fits the question, adding examination findings, observations and results.
  5. A structured report follows, typically in under a minute, ending with numbered references read from PubMed and ClinicalTrials.gov and, when named medicines are involved, their US product information from DailyMed.

Because a consultation can start in any engine, the same answers can serve different questions. Diagnostic Reasoning suits an undifferentiated problem; Geriatrics and Medication Review an older patient with a long medicine list; Medication Safety a planned change of prescription; and Peri-operative Assessment a patient being prepared for surgery. The form gathers the history; interpretation and the consultation stay with the clinician.

What a patient-completed history is good for

  • Time: background history is gathered before the consultation, so more of the appointment goes on the problem itself.
  • Completeness: past medical, family and social history and a systems review are less likely to be cut short than in a hurried interview.
  • The patient's own account and priorities, which are easily lost when a history is summarised by someone else.
  • Reflection: patients can check dates, previous operations and the names of their medicines at home rather than recall them on the spot.
  • Sensitive topics: the way questions are put affects what patients disclose, and a meta-analysis has compared computer-assisted, written self-administered and face-to-face screening for intimate partner violence [1].

What must be confirmed

ItemWhy it needs checkingHow to check
The presenting complaint and its timelinePatients may list several problems, or lead with the one that worries them leastAsk what concerns them most and when it began
Red-flag symptomsA form cannot capture severity, progression or context reliablyAsk directly, and examine
MedicinesOmissions and discrepancies are common, and an accurate list needs several sources [2]Reconcile with the patient, their packets, the pharmacy and the primary care record
AllergiesPenicillin allergy is recorded in roughly one in ten hospital patients, yet few of those records reflect a clinically significant allergy [3]Ask what happened, when and how it was treated; validated tools such as PEN-FAST identify low-risk labels [4]
Medical termsWords such as migraine, angina or stroke may be used looselyAsk what the patient actually experienced
Who completed the formA relative or carer may have filled it inNote the source of the information
How current it isThe answers may be days oldAsk what has changed since

Turning answers into a good consultation

An engine works from what it is given. The patient's answers provide the history; the clinician supplies what the form cannot: examination findings, observations, results with units, imaging reports and their own impression of how unwell the patient looks. A short, specific question gets a more useful report than a general request, for example: which diagnoses must be excluded today, which of these medicines should stop, or what needs optimising before this operation.

Read the report with the same scrutiny as any second opinion. Check that it has understood the history correctly, that any score it applied used the right inputs, and that its recommendations fit the patient in front of you. The numbered references allow each key statement to be traced to its source.

A worked example

An 83-year-old is referred to a medical clinic after two falls. Her intake answers list nine medicines, including a hypnotic and a bladder antimuscarinic, describe dizziness on standing, and mention that her daughter now does her shopping.

  1. At the appointment the clinician confirms the medicine list against her packets and the pharmacy record, and finds that a diuretic she listed was stopped months ago.
  2. The clinician measures lying and standing blood pressure, checks gait and adds her recent kidney function and sodium.
  3. A consultation is started in the Geriatrics and Medication Review engine from her answers, with these findings added and a focused question: what should stop or change to reduce her risk of falling?
  4. The report sets out each medicine with its indication, the concern and a recommendation, with tapering and monitoring, and the clinician agrees the changes with the patient and her daughter.

Limits and responsibilities

  • A form cannot examine the patient, and it cannot notice what the patient does not mention.
  • Patients with limited literacy, a language barrier, visual impairment or cognitive impairment may need help to complete it, or a conventional interview instead.
  • An intake form is not a triage tool. Patients with symptoms that may need urgent care should be assessed directly, following local triage arrangements.
  • The engines support clinical judgement and do not replace it. They are for clinicians, not for patients to diagnose themselves.
  • Follow your institution's policy on sending links to patients and on how patient-provided information is recorded and used.

The clinician remains responsible for every decision made after reviewing the answers and the report.

How Sana Health helps

From a patient's intake answers, the clinician can start a consultation in any of the 38 engines. In the Diagnostic Reasoning engine the answers supply the history, and once the clinician adds examination findings, observations and results, the engine works through the case to a ranked differential, the reasoning behind it, the red flags and the tests that would change the picture. The report typically arrives in under a minute and ends with numbered references read from PubMed and ClinicalTrials.gov when the question is asked.

Questions

Can a patient-completed form replace history-taking?

No. It gathers background efficiently, but the presenting complaint, red flags, medicines and allergies still need confirming with the patient, and nothing replaces examination. Treat the form as a well-prepared starting point.

Which engine should be used with a patient's intake answers?

Any of the 38 engines can start from the answers. Choose by the question: Diagnostic Reasoning for an undifferentiated problem, Medication Safety or Geriatrics and Medication Review for a long medicine list, or the specialty engine that matches the presenting problem.

Should an intake form be used for urgent symptoms?

No. It is not a triage tool. A patient whose symptoms may need urgent care should be assessed directly, following local triage arrangements.

References