Many patients arrive without a diagnosis: breathless, confused, febrile or simply unwell, with findings that point in several directions. The diagnostic process runs from gathering information, through integrating and interpreting it, to generating hypotheses and confirming one, and each step is harder when the history is limited and the clinical, laboratory and imaging features are non-specific [1]. Diagnostic error is a recognised patient-safety problem across clinical settings, including the emergency department [2], and flawed clinical reasoning is associated with diagnostic errors and inappropriate investigations [3].
Experienced clinicians recognise many presentations quickly. Research on diagnostic reasoning describes two processes: a rapid, largely automatic retrieval of possible diagnoses based on experience, and a slower, analytical application of formal knowledge [4]. Neither is reliable on its own, and the high cognitive load of acute and intensive care makes both harder to use well [5]. A structured approach makes the analytical step explicit, so that it can be checked by the clinician, a colleague or a senior.