Clinical article · Pathways and documents

Pre-authorisation requests: documenting medical necessity so the claim is understood

Written for
Hospital physicians, emergency doctors and residents
Reading time
6 minutes
Published
Updated

Written by the Sana Health team for clinicians. It summarises published guidance, is not a guideline and has not been peer reviewed. Check current local protocols before acting.

Key points

  • The person who approves a request has not seen the patient; the document has to carry the clinical reasoning on its own.
  • A complete request states the diagnosis, the findings that establish it, the criteria or score met, why treatment is needed now, the alternatives, and the expected stay by level of care.
  • Dated observations, results with units and named guideline criteria persuade; adjectives such as 'severe' or 'critical' without evidence do not.
  • Reply to a query point by point with the dated facts, and keep to what the case sheet shows.
  • Never strengthen a diagnosis or severity to secure approval; if the documented facts fall short of a scheme's criteria, say so and explain why the treatment is still proposed.
  • Formats and required documents differ between insurers and schemes, so the current scheme manual and the hospital's own format apply.

Why the wording matters

Pre-authorisation is meant to confirm that a treatment is appropriate before it is funded, but it can delay care. A systematic review of prior authorisation in the United States found that, besides delays, it was associated with disease exacerbation, preventable hospitalisation and prolonged hospital stay [1], and a scoping review in neurology described barriers to timely treatment for patients and clinicians [2]. A clear first request is the simplest way to avoid a query and the delay that follows it.

In India, government-funded insurance has expanded through successive national schemes, from the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana to the Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana [3, 4], alongside private insurers and third-party administrators. Each has its own forms, packages and document requirements, which change over time. This article describes documentation practice that applies to all of them; the current scheme manual or insurer guidance, and the hospital's own format, decide the details.

The medical record is read by insurers and, at times, by courts as well as by clinicians [5]. What is written in a request must match the case sheet, the investigation reports and the discharge summary.

The six elements of a medical necessity statement

  1. The diagnosis in standard terms, written out in full, with secondary diagnoses and complications that affect treatment, and the certainty stated.
  2. The findings that establish it: dated and timed observations, examination findings, ECG, imaging and laboratory results with units and reference ranges.
  3. The severity, expressed through the named criteria, classification or score the patient meets rather than through adjectives.
  4. The proposed treatment and why it is needed now, tied to the guideline that recommends it and to what would happen if it were delayed.
  5. The alternatives considered and why each is unsuitable for this patient.
  6. The expected stay by level of care, intensive care, high dependency or ward, with the reason for each day and the planned investigations.

Documentation shapes how acuity, quality and reimbursement are measured, which is why the diagnosis and its severity need to be recorded precisely [6]. Diagnosis and procedure codes should be assigned by the coding team from the clinical record, because coded categories do not always reflect the clinical picture [10], and studies of coded data, for example in sepsis, have had to test how faithfully they capture the clinical diagnosis [11].

A worked example

For a man of 62 with an inferior ST-elevation myocardial infarction treated by primary angioplasty, the elements might read as follows. Bracketed items are placeholders for facts the clinician must supply.

ElementExample wording
DiagnosisAcute inferior ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI)
FindingsCentral chest pain from [time]; ECG at [time] showing ST elevation in leads II, III and aVF; troponin [value, units, reference range]; blood pressure and heart rate [values] at presentation
SeverityKillip class [class]; [any arrhythmia, hypotension or heart failure]
Treatment and urgencyPrimary percutaneous coronary intervention with one drug-eluting stent to the right coronary artery at [time]; primary PCI is the recommended reperfusion strategy for STEMI when it can be delivered promptly [7, 8]
AlternativesFibrinolysis not used because [primary PCI available within the recommended time, or contraindication]
Expected stayDay 1 in the coronary care unit for rhythm and access-site monitoring; days 2 to 4 on the ward for [mobilisation, echocardiography, secondary prevention and education]

Replying to a query or a denial

  1. Restate the question exactly as it was asked.
  2. Work through the items in turn, giving for each what the record shows and when: the day of illness, the observations, the results and their trend, the treatment given and the response.
  3. Name the guideline or criteria that support the decision, and attach the reports that show each fact.
  4. Keep to the record. Do not argue, and do not add findings that are not documented.

For a query about a six-day stay for dengue with warning signs, the reply would set out, day by day, the warning signs present, the haematocrit and platelet trend, the intravenous fluid given and the response, and the criteria that defined readiness for discharge. Close monitoring through the critical phase is central to dengue care [9], and showing how each day was used answers the question better than a general statement that the patient was unwell.

Common reasons requests are queried

  • A diagnosis that the attached results do not show
  • Severity asserted without criteria, scores or measurements
  • A length of stay with no reason given for each day or level of care
  • Inconsistency between the case sheet, the request and the discharge summary
  • Missing dates and times, especially for time-critical treatment
  • Copied or cloned notes that do not match the day they are dated [5]

Overstating a diagnosis, a severity or a duration to obtain approval is misrepresentation, with professional and legal consequences. If the facts do not meet a scheme's criteria but treatment is still clinically justified, say so plainly and explain the clinical reasoning.

How Sana Health helps

Insurance and Medico-legal Documents drafts a pre-authorisation request or a reply to a query from the facts the clinician supplies: the diagnosis in standard terms, the findings that establish it, the criteria or score met, why treatment is needed now with the supporting guideline, the alternatives, and the expected stay by level of care. It keeps every finding as documented, leaves labelled blanks for missing facts and identifiers, and marks any code it proposes for the coding team to verify. Its checks point out where the facts fall short of the request.

Questions

What does medical necessity mean in a pre-authorisation request?

It means showing that the proposed treatment is appropriate and needed for this patient now: the diagnosis, the evidence for it, its severity against named criteria, the guideline basis for the treatment, why alternatives are unsuitable and why the stay at each level of care is required.

How can I reduce insurance queries on hospital claims?

Write the request so that it stands alone: dated findings with units, named criteria rather than adjectives, a reason for each day of stay, and consistency between the case sheet, the request and the discharge summary. Use the insurer's or scheme's current format and attach the reports that show each fact.

Should the treating doctor assign the ICD codes on a claim?

The doctor should document the diagnoses and procedures clearly and completely; assigning codes is usually the role of trained coding staff, following the hospital's process and the scheme's or insurer's rules. Suggested codes should be confirmed by the coding team.

References

  1. Adverse effects of health plan prior authorization on clinical effectiveness and patient outcomes: A systematic review (opens in a new tab)Am J Med, 2026
  2. Barriers and Consequences of Prior Authorization for Neurologic Medications: A Scoping Review (opens in a new tab)JAMA Neurol, 2026
  3. Evolution of Government-funded health insurance for universal health coverage in India (opens in a new tab)Lancet Reg Health Southeast Asia, 2023
  4. The Ayushman Bharat Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana and the path to universal health coverage in India: Overcoming the challenges of stewardship and governance (opens in a new tab)PLoS Med, 2019
  5. Copy, paste, and cloned notes in electronic health records: prevalence, benefits, risks, and best practice recommendations (opens in a new tab)Chest, 2014
  6. Clinical Documentation for Intensivists: The Impact of Diagnosis Documentation (opens in a new tab)Crit Care Med, 2020
  7. 2025 ACC/AHA/ACEP/NAEMSP/SCAI Guideline for the Management of Patients With Acute Coronary Syndromes: A Report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Joint Committee on Clinical Practice Guidelines (opens in a new tab)Circulation, 2025
  8. 2017 ESC Guidelines for the management of acute myocardial infarction in patients presenting with ST-segment elevation: The Task Force for the management of acute myocardial infarction in patients presenting with ST-segment elevation of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) (opens in a new tab)Eur Heart J, 2018
  9. Dengue (opens in a new tab)Lancet, 2024
  10. International classification of disease coding for obstructive lung disease: does it reflect appropriate clinical documentation? (opens in a new tab)Chest, 2010
  11. Validity of administrative data in recording sepsis: a systematic review (opens in a new tab)Crit Care, 2015